
When I wrote “
A Semi-Pragmatic Less Theological Open Letter to Egalitarians” I figured that I would get a couple responses…maybe three to four. I was a bit surprised when many more people were willing to answer my question. I was (and continue to be) grateful for the interaction with those who have a different view of biblical roles than I do.
Now that the “open letter” is officially closed (since it ended on Dec. 31, 2008), I thought I would give a few thoughts to the responses.
Overall, I’m not sure the letter was that helpful. I think it did bring some clarity to how egalitarians think and it did bring more interaction with egalitarian in my “inbox,” so I am grateful for the friendships I am building, but overall, it seemed to me to be yet another debate in cyberspace that went on and on until everyone got bored with it…and probably moved on to another debate.
Personally, I think the practical questions are important because they show the true groundwork theology that people believe. I find it hard to believe that you can reconcile an egalitarian lifestyle if you are trying to submit to all of Scripture. Many (almost 78 people) disagree with me on this, but my conscience still rests with my reading of the English Bible (with my Greek Bible Works program) to see what the original author intended by what he said.
In writing the “Open Letter,” I also had some surprises. First, I learned why Wayne Grudem and others never write a second open letter. It is because you will never be able to adequately respond to all of the questions, comments, judgments, and genuine interactions that come from the first one. Secondly, I think I hit a nerve with some readers. Many assumptions were made about me, my marriage, my family, and my parenting because of what I wrote and how I asked the questions. I must say that I grew in the sanctification process through the blog post…and I am thankful to the Lord for that. Thirdly, it was interesting to me that many commenters desired more to argue with how and why I asked the question rather than answer the questions. Many did not even answer the questions, but simple argued about answering the questions.
To the egalitarians who commented, I would like to say “thank you.” I am grateful for the many e-mails I’ve received and beginning communication to clarify both of our positions. Let’s continue the conversation in e-mails and phone calls and in more personal ways that comments cannot provide. May God’s truth ring true and this debate and let the heat of the debate refine all of us.